Controller support? (ng)

[brychanrobot]

On the stable release version of the AppImage I can use my PS4 controller, but I installed an ng version (https://github.com/ChristopherHX/linux-packaging-scripts/actions/runs/248443847) in order to be able to use newer versions of the minecraft APK and keyboard/mouse works, but gamepad support seems to be broken. I'm getting LinuxJoystick::pool error in the log. Is this a known issue?

[ChristopherHX]

Not yet implemented in this feature branch.

[ChristopherHX]

Does it work now for you with the latest ng.AppImage update?

[brychanrobot]

I tried https://github.com/ChristopherHX/linux-packaging-scripts/actions/runs/278450003 (I think that's the one you wanted me to try), and it crashed with this log. If it helps, I'm using a PS4 controller on Manjaro Gnome 20.1.

17:05:47 Trace [HybrisUtils] Loaded OS library libz.so.1
17:05:47 Trace [HybrisUtils] Loaded OS library libm.so.6
17:05:47 Trace [HybrisUtils] Loaded OS library /tmp/.mount_Minecrp7wXOg/usr/share/mcpelauncher/lib/native/x86/libfmod.so.12.0
17:05:47 Info  [Launcher] Loading gamepad mappings
17:05:47 Trace [Launcher] Loading gamepad mappings: /usr/local/share//mcpelauncher/gamecontrollerdb.txt
17:05:47 Trace [Launcher] Loading gamepad mappings: /tmp/.mount_Minecrp7wXOg/usr/share/mcpelauncher/gamecontrollerdb.txt
17:05:47 Info  [Launcher] Creating window
libevdev_new_from_fd error -22 (/dev/input/js0)
17:05:47 Trace [WindowCallbacks] Gamepad connected #0
17:05:47 Info  [Minecraft] android_main starting. internalDataPath is '../data/', externalDataPath is '../data/'
17:05:47 Info  [Minecraft] NO LOG FILE! - AppPlatform_android::setStorageDirectory - using External dir - CurrentFileStoragePath is now '/home/bryant/.local/share/mcpelauncher/'
17:05:47 Warn  [Launcher] EGL stub eglMakeCurrent called
17:05:47 Warn  [Launcher] EGL stub eglMakeCurrent called
17:05:47 Warn  [Launcher] EGL stub eglMakeCurrent called
17:05:47 Warn  [Minecraft] NO LOG FILE! - [Device Lost] The graphics context was gained
17:05:47 Warn  [Minecraft] MinecraftGame::init && MinecraftGame::setSize!
Signal 11 received
Backtrace elements: 7
#0 /tmp/.mount_Minecrp7wXOg/usr/bin/./mcpelauncher-client32(_ZN12CrashHandler12handleSignalEiPv+0xf1) [0x87eb271]
#1 linux-gate.so.1(__kernel_sigreturn+0) [0xf7f42580]
#2 /tmp/.mount_Minecrp7wXOg/usr/bin/./mcpelauncher-client32() [0x87b5456]
#3 /tmp/.mount_Minecrp7wXOg/usr/bin/./mcpelauncher-client32(_ZN14FakeInputQueue11finishEventEP14FakeInputEvent+0x20) [0x87b4d00]
#4 /tmp/.mount_Minecrp7wXOg/usr/bin/./mcpelauncher-client32() [0x87b4f03]
#5 /tmp/.mount_Minecrp7wXOg/usr/bin/./mcpelauncher-client32() [0x87b4ec5]
#6 HYBRIS (null)+0x47e in /home/bryant/.local/share/mcpelauncher/versions/1.16.40.02/lib/x86/libminecraftpe.so+0x0x810bae [0x0xdeb10bae]
Dumping stack...
#24 HYBRIS (null)+0xe3fe8a68 in /home/bryant/.local/share/mcpelauncher/versions/1.16.40.02/lib/x86/libminecraftpe.so+0x0x5ce8a68 [0x0xe3fe8a68]
#186 HYBRIS GameControllerHandler_Android::processRightTrigger(int, int, AInputEvent*)+0x13a in /home/bryant/.local/share/mcpelauncher/versions/1.16.40.02/lib/x86/libminecraftpe.so+0x0x80acba [0x0xdeb0acba]
#213 HYBRIS GameControllerHandler_Android::processRightTrigger(int, int, AInputEvent*)+0x13a in /home/bryant/.local/share/mcpelauncher/versions/1.16.40.02/lib/x86/libminecraftpe.so+0x0x80acba [0x0xdeb0acba]
#446 HYBRIS GameController::_feedStick(int, GameControllerStickState, float, float, int)+0xc in /home/bryant/.local/share/mcpelauncher/versions/1.16.40.02/lib/x86/libminecraftpe.so+0x0x3e1d5ac [0x0xe211d5ac]
#472 HYBRIS (null)+0xe3fe8a68 in /home/bryant/.local/share/mcpelauncher/versions/1.16.40.02/lib/x86/libminecraftpe.so+0x0x5ce8a68 [0x0xe3fe8a68]
#474 HYBRIS std::__ndk1::__shared_weak_count::__release_weak()+0xf in /home/bryant/.local/share/mcpelauncher/versions/1.16.40.02/lib/x86/libc++_shared.so+0x0x8bfdf [0x0xe468bfdf]
#480 HYBRIS (null)+0xe3fe8a68 in /home/bryant/.local/share/mcpelauncher/versions/1.16.40.02/lib/x86/libminecraftpe.so+0x0x5ce8a68 [0x0xe3fe8a68]
#482 HYBRIS GameControllerHandler_Android::processRightTrigger(int, int, AInputEvent*)+0x1f4 in /home/bryant/.local/share/mcpelauncher/versions/1.16.40.02/lib/x86/libminecraftpe.so+0x0x80ad74 [0x0xdeb0ad74]
#505 HYBRIS (null)+0xe3fe8a68 in /home/bryant/.local/share/mcpelauncher/versions/1.16.40.02/lib/x86/libminecraftpe.so+0x0x5ce8a68 [0x0xe3fe8a68]
#536 HYBRIS (null)+0xe3fe8a68 in /home/bryant/.local/share/mcpelauncher/versions/1.16.40.02/lib/x86/libminecraftpe.so+0x0x5ce8a68 [0x0xe3fe8a68]
#538 HYBRIS (null)+0x47e in /home/bryant/.local/share/mcpelauncher/versions/1.16.40.02/lib/x86/libminecraftpe.so+0x0x810bae [0x0xdeb10bae]
#548 HYBRIS MainAndroid::Internal::JNIQueueToMainThreadTaskGroup+(nil) in /home/bryant/.local/share/mcpelauncher/versions/1.16.40.02/lib/x86/libminecraftpe.so+0x0x5d10208 [0x0xe4010208]
#553 HYBRIS (null)+0xe2ac802b in /home/bryant/.local/share/mcpelauncher/versions/1.16.40.02/lib/x86/libminecraftpe.so+0x0x47c802b [0x0xe2ac802b]
#561 HYBRIS (null)+0xe3e58534 in /home/bryant/.local/share/mcpelauncher/versions/1.16.40.02/lib/x86/libminecraftpe.so+0x0x5b58534 [0x0xe3e58534]
#575 HYBRIS (null)+0xe3e584ec in /home/bryant/.local/share/mcpelauncher/versions/1.16.40.02/lib/x86/libminecraftpe.so+0x0x5b584ec [0x0xe3e584ec]
#584 HYBRIS (null)+0xe3fe8a68 in /home/bryant/.local/share/mcpelauncher/versions/1.16.40.02/lib/x86/libminecraftpe.so+0x0x5ce8a68 [0x0xe3fe8a68]
#586 HYBRIS (null)+0xdeb27009 in /home/bryant/.local/share/mcpelauncher/versions/1.16.40.02/lib/x86/libminecraftpe.so+0x0x827009 [0x0xdeb27009]
#607 HYBRIS (null)+(nil) in /home/bryant/.local/share/mcpelauncher/versions/1.16.40.02/lib/x86/libminecraftpe.so+0x0x80d160 [0x0xdeb0d160]
#611 HYBRIS (null)+(nil) in /home/bryant/.local/share/mcpelauncher/versions/1.16.40.02/lib/x86/libminecraftpe.so+0x0x80cfd0 [0x0xdeb0cfd0]
#612 HYBRIS (null)+(nil) in /home/bryant/.local/share/mcpelauncher/versions/1.16.40.02/lib/x86/libminecraftpe.so+0x0x80cfd0 [0x0xdeb0cfd0]
#613 HYBRIS (null)+(nil) in /home/bryant/.local/share/mcpelauncher/versions/1.16.40.02/lib/x86/libminecraftpe.so+0x0x41a7c90 [0x0xe24a7c90]
#614 HYBRIS (null)+(nil) in /home/bryant/.local/share/mcpelauncher/versions/1.16.40.02/lib/x86/libminecraftpe.so+0x0x41a8860 [0x0xe24a8860]
#685 HYBRIS (null)+0xdeb26f20 in /home/bryant/.local/share/mcpelauncher/versions/1.16.40.02/lib/x86/libminecraftpe.so+0x0x826f20 [0x0xdeb26f20]
#690 HYBRIS (null)+(nil) in /home/bryant/.local/share/mcpelauncher/versions/1.16.40.02/lib/x86/libminecraftpe.so+0x0x80d160 [0x0xdeb0d160]
#691 HYBRIS (null)+0xdeb26730 in /home/bryant/.local/share/mcpelauncher/versions/1.16.40.02/lib/x86/libminecraftpe.so+0x0x826730 [0x0xdeb26730]
#692 HYBRIS (null)+0xdeb267e0 in /home/bryant/.local/share/mcpelauncher/versions/1.16.40.02/lib/x86/libminecraftpe.so+0x0x8267e0 [0x0xdeb267e0]
#693 HYBRIS (null)+0xdeb26890 in /home/bryant/.local/share/mcpelauncher/versions/1.16.40.02/lib/x86/libminecraftpe.so+0x0x826890 [0x0xdeb26890]
#694 HYBRIS (null)+0xdeb26970 in /home/bryant/.local/share/mcpelauncher/versions/1.16.40.02/lib/x86/libminecraftpe.so+0x0x826970 [0x0xdeb26970]
#695 HYBRIS (null)+0xdeb26a20 in /home/bryant/.local/share/mcpelauncher/versions/1.16.40.02/lib/x86/libminecraftpe.so+0x0x826a20 [0x0xdeb26a20]
#696 HYBRIS (null)+0xdeb26640 in /home/bryant/.local/share/mcpelauncher/versions/1.16.40.02/lib/x86/libminecraftpe.so+0x0x826640 [0x0xdeb26640]
#697 HYBRIS (null)+0xdeb1ac40 in /home/bryant/.local/share/mcpelauncher/versions/1.16.40.02/lib/x86/libminecraftpe.so+0x0x81ac40 [0x0xdeb1ac40]
#698 HYBRIS (null)+0xdeb26c30 in /home/bryant/.local/share/mcpelauncher/versions/1.16.40.02/lib/x86/libminecraftpe.so+0x0x826c30 [0x0xdeb26c30]
#701 HYBRIS (null)+0xdeb26d50 in /home/bryant/.local/share/mcpelauncher/versions/1.16.40.02/lib/x86/libminecraftpe.so+0x0x826d50 [0x0xdeb26d50]
#702 HYBRIS (null)+0xdeb26e10 in /home/bryant/.local/share/mcpelauncher/versions/1.16.40.02/lib/x86/libminecraftpe.so+0x0x826e10 [0x0xdeb26e10]
#703 HYBRIS (null)+0xdeb26e40 in /home/bryant/.local/share/mcpelauncher/versions/1.16.40.02/lib/x86/libminecraftpe.so+0x0x826e40 [0x0xdeb26e40]
#705 HYBRIS (null)+0xdeb26ad0 in /home/bryant/.local/share/mcpelauncher/versions/1.16.40.02/lib/x86/libminecraftpe.so+0x0x826ad0 [0x0xdeb26ad0]
#706 HYBRIS (null)+0xdeb26b40 in /home/bryant/.local/share/mcpelauncher/versions/1.16.40.02/lib/x86/libminecraftpe.so+0x0x826b40 [0x0xdeb26b40]
#718 HYBRIS (null)+(nil) in /home/bryant/.local/share/mcpelauncher/versions/1.16.40.02/lib/x86/libminecraftpe.so+0x0x80cfd0 [0x0xdeb0cfd0]

Process exited with unexpected exit code: 6

[ChristopherHX]

I think, that is one reason why the ng controller crashs so often.
there is undefined behavior if only the gamepad is used as input.
https://github.com/minecraft-linux/mcpelauncher-client/blob/06951bde7ab56edeed3b02743b21e0fbc784fa1d/src/fake_inputqueue.cpp#L76

At least your controller got recognized by the launcher, should be fixed in 0.1-rp3.

[ChristopherHX]

Do you know that all AppImages which are built by this scripts are uploaded to https://github.com/ChristopherHX/linux-packaging-scripts/releases/tag/ng.appimage and via the integrated zsync updater? Downloading 100MB vs. 4MB, known to fail on some distros.

I could reproduce this crash after testing gamepads with the AppImage Fixed.

[brychanrobot]

Thanks! I can confirm that the latest version works for me.