[Dapr] Prompt user for existing Dapr installation during extension create

src/k8s-extension/azext_k8s_extension/partner_extensions/Dapr.py

@@ -4,43 +4,143 @@
 # --------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
 
 # pylint: disable=unused-argument
-# pylint: disable=line-too-long
 # pylint: disable=too-many-locals
+# pylint: disable=too-many-instance-attributes
 
+from typing import Tuple
+
+from azure.cli.core.azclierror import InvalidArgumentValueError
+from knack.log import get_logger
+from knack.prompting import prompt, prompt_y_n
+
+from ..vendored_sdks.models import Extension, Scope, ScopeCluster
 from .DefaultExtension import DefaultExtension
 
-from ..vendored_sdks.models import (
-    Extension,
-)
+logger = get_logger(__name__)
 
 
 class Dapr(DefaultExtension):
     def __init__(self):
+        self.TSG_LINK = "https://docs.microsoft.com/en-us/azure/aks/dapr"
+        self.DEFAULT_RELEASE_NAME = 'dapr'
+        self.DEFAULT_RELEASE_NAMESPACE = 'dapr-system'
+        self.DEFAULT_RELEASE_TRAIN = 'stable'
+        self.DEFAULT_CLUSTER_TYPE = 'managedclusters'
+        self.DEFAULT_HA = 'true'
+
         # constants for configuration settings.
-        self.CLUSTER_TYPE = 'global.clusterType'
+        self.CLUSTER_TYPE_KEY = 'global.clusterType'
+        self.HA_KEY_ENABLED_KEY = 'global.ha.enabled'
+        self.SKIP_EXISTING_DAPR_CHECK_KEY = 'skipExistingDaprCheck'
+        self.EXISTING_DAPR_RELEASE_NAME_KEY = 'existingDaprReleaseName'
+        self.EXISTING_DAPR_RELEASE_NAMESPACE_KEY = 'existingDaprReleaseNamespace'
+
+        # constants for message prompts.
+        self.MSG_IS_DAPR_INSTALLED = "Is Dapr already installed in the cluster?"
+        self.MSG_ENTER_RELEASE_NAME = "Enter the Helm release name for Dapr, "\
+            f"or press Enter to use the default name [{self.DEFAULT_RELEASE_NAME}]: "
+        self.MSG_ENTER_RELEASE_NAMESPACE = "Enter the namespace where Dapr is installed, "\
+            f"or press Enter to use the default namespace [{self.DEFAULT_RELEASE_NAMESPACE}]: "
+        self.MSG_WARN_EXISTING_INSTALLATION = "The extension will use your existing Dapr installation. "\
+            f"Note, if you have updated the default values for global.ha.* or dapr_placement.* in your existing "\
+            "Dapr installation, you must provide them via --configuration-settings. Failing to do so will result in"\
+            "an error, since Helm upgrade will try to modify the StatefulSet."\
+            f"Please refer to {self.TSG_LINK} for more information."
+
+        self.RELEASE_INFO_HELP_STRING = "The Helm release name and namespace can be found by running 'helm list -A'."
+
+        # constants for error messages.
+        self.ERR_MSG_INVALID_SCOPE_TPL = "Invalid scope '{}'. This extension can be installed only at 'cluster' scope."\
+            f" Check {self.TSG_LINK} for more information."
+
+    def _get_release_info(self, release_name: str, release_namespace: str, configuration_settings: dict)\
+            -> Tuple[str, str, bool]:
+        '''
+        Check if Dapr is already installed in the cluster and get the release name and namespace.
+        If user has provided the release name and namespace in configuration settings, use those.
+        Otherwise, prompt the user for the release name and namespace.
+        If Dapr is not installed, return the default release name and namespace.
+        '''
+        name, namespace, dapr_exists = release_name, release_namespace, False
+
+        # Set the default release name and namespace if not provided.
+        name = name or self.DEFAULT_RELEASE_NAME
+        namespace = namespace or self.DEFAULT_RELEASE_NAMESPACE
+
+        if configuration_settings.get(self.SKIP_EXISTING_DAPR_CHECK_KEY, 'false') == 'true':
+            logger.info("%s is set to true, skipping existing Dapr check.", self.SKIP_EXISTING_DAPR_CHECK_KEY)
+            return name, namespace, False
+
+        cfg_name = configuration_settings.get(self.EXISTING_DAPR_RELEASE_NAME_KEY, None)
+        cfg_namespace = configuration_settings.get(self.EXISTING_DAPR_RELEASE_NAMESPACE_KEY, None)
 
-    def Create(self, cmd, client, resource_group_name, cluster_name, name, cluster_type, cluster_rp,
-               extension_type, scope, auto_upgrade_minor_version, release_train, version, target_namespace,
-               release_namespace, configuration_settings, configuration_protected_settings,
-               configuration_settings_file, configuration_protected_settings_file):
+        # If the user has specified the release name and namespace in configuration settings, then use it.
+        if cfg_name and cfg_namespace:
+            logger.info("Using the release name and namespace specified in the configuration settings.")
+            return cfg_name, cfg_namespace, True
 
+        # If either release name or namespace is missing, ignore the configuration settings and prompt the user.
+        if cfg_name or cfg_namespace:
+            logger.warning("Both '%s' and '%s' must be specified via --configuration-settings. Only one of them is "
+                           "specified, ignoring.", self.EXISTING_DAPR_RELEASE_NAME_KEY,
+                           self.EXISTING_DAPR_RELEASE_NAMESPACE_KEY)
+
+        # Check explictly if Dapr is already installed in the cluster.
+        # If so, reuse the release name and namespace to avoid conflicts.
+        if prompt_y_n(self.MSG_IS_DAPR_INSTALLED, default='n'):
+            dapr_exists = True
+
+            name = prompt(self.MSG_ENTER_RELEASE_NAME, self.RELEASE_INFO_HELP_STRING) or self.DEFAULT_RELEASE_NAME
+            if release_name and name != release_name:
+                logger.warning("The release name has been changed from '%s' to '%s'.", release_name, name)
+
+            namespace = prompt(self.MSG_ENTER_RELEASE_NAMESPACE, self.RELEASE_INFO_HELP_STRING)\
+                or self.DEFAULT_RELEASE_NAMESPACE
+            if release_namespace and namespace != release_namespace:
+                logger.warning("The release namespace has been changed from '%s' to '%s'.",
+                               release_namespace, namespace)
+
+        return name, namespace, dapr_exists
+
+    def Create(self, cmd, client, resource_group_name: str, cluster_name: str, name: str, cluster_type: str,
+               cluster_rp: str, extension_type: str, scope: str, auto_upgrade_minor_version: bool,
+               release_train: str, version: str, target_namespace: str, release_namespace: str,
+               configuration_settings: dict, configuration_protected_settings: dict,
+               configuration_settings_file: str, configuration_protected_settings_file: str):
         """ExtensionType 'Microsoft.Dapr' specific validations & defaults for Create
            Must create and return a valid 'ExtensionInstance' object.
         """
 
-        if cluster_type.lower() == '' or cluster_type.lower() == 'managedclusters':
-            configuration_settings[self.CLUSTER_TYPE] = 'managedclusters'
+        # Dapr extension is only supported at the cluster scope.
+        if scope == 'namespace':
+            raise InvalidArgumentValueError(self.ERR_MSG_INVALID_SCOPE_TPL.format(scope))
+
+        release_name, release_namespace, dapr_exists = \
+            self._get_release_info(name, release_namespace, configuration_settings)
+
+        # Inform the user that the extension will be installed on an existing Dapr installation.
+        # Disable HA mode if Dapr is already installed in the cluster.
+        if dapr_exists:
+            logger.warning(self.MSG_WARN_EXISTING_INSTALLATION)
+            if self.HA_KEY_ENABLED_KEY not in configuration_settings:
+                configuration_settings[self.HA_KEY_ENABLED_KEY] = 'false'
+
+        scope_cluster = ScopeCluster(release_namespace=release_namespace or self.DEFAULT_RELEASE_NAMESPACE)
+        extension_scope = Scope(cluster=scope_cluster, namespace=None)
+
+        if cluster_type.lower() == '' or cluster_type.lower() == self.DEFAULT_CLUSTER_TYPE:
+            configuration_settings[self.CLUSTER_TYPE_KEY] = self.DEFAULT_CLUSTER_TYPE
 
         create_identity = False
         extension_instance = Extension(
             extension_type=extension_type,
             auto_upgrade_minor_version=auto_upgrade_minor_version,
-            release_train=release_train,
+            release_train=release_train or self.DEFAULT_RELEASE_TRAIN,
             version=version,
-            scope=scope,
+            scope=extension_scope,
             configuration_settings=configuration_settings,
             configuration_protected_settings=configuration_protected_settings,
             identity=None,
             location=""
         )
-        return extension_instance, name, create_identity
+        return extension_instance, release_name, create_identity

src/k8s-extension/azext_k8s_extension/tests/latest/test_k8s_extension_scenario.py

@@ -28,7 +28,7 @@ def test_k8s_extension(self):
 
         self.cmd('k8s-extension create -g {rg} -n {name} -c {cluster_name} --cluster-type {cluster_type} '
                  '--extension-type {extension_type} --release-train {release_train} --version {version} '
-                 '--no-wait')
+                 '--configuration-settings "skipExistingDaprCheck=true" --no-wait')
 
         # Update requires agent running in k8s cluster that is connected to Azure - so no update tests here
         # self.cmd('k8s-extension update -g {rg} -n {name} --tags foo=boo', checks=[

testing/test/extensions/public/Dapr.Tests.ps1

@@ -0,0 +1,63 @@
+Describe 'DAPR Testing' {
+    BeforeAll {
+        $extensionType = "microsoft.dapr"
+        $extensionName = "dapr"
+        $clusterType = "connectedClusters"
+
+        . $PSScriptRoot/../../helper/Constants.ps1
+        . $PSScriptRoot/../../helper/Helper.ps1
+    }
+
+    It 'Creates the extension and checks that it onboards correctly' {
+        $output = az $Env:K8sExtensionName create -c $($ENVCONFIG.arcClusterName) -g $($ENVCONFIG.resourceGroup) --cluster-type $clusterType -n $extensionName --extension-type $extensionType --configuration-settings "skipExistingDaprCheck=true" --no-wait
+        $? | Should -BeTrue
+
+        $n = 0
+        do 
+        {
+            $output = az $Env:K8sExtensionName show -c $($ENVCONFIG.arcClusterName) -g $($ENVCONFIG.resourceGroup) --cluster-type $clusterType -n $extensionName
+            $provisioningState = ($output | ConvertFrom-Json).provisioningState
+            Write-Host "Provisioning State: $provisioningState"
+            if ($provisioningState -eq "Succeeded") {
+                break
+            }
+            Start-Sleep -Seconds 40
+            $n += 1
+        } while ($n -le $MAX_RETRY_ATTEMPTS)
+        $n | Should -BeLessOrEqual $MAX_RETRY_ATTEMPTS
+    }
+
+    It "Performs a show on the extension" {
+        $output = az $Env:K8sExtensionName show -c $($ENVCONFIG.arcClusterName) -g $($ENVCONFIG.resourceGroup) --cluster-type $clusterType -n $extensionName
+        $? | Should -BeTrue
+        $output | Should -Not -BeNullOrEmpty
+    }
+
+    It "Lists the extensions on the cluster" {
+        $output = az $Env:K8sExtensionName list -c $($ENVCONFIG.arcClusterName) -g $($ENVCONFIG.resourceGroup) --cluster-type $clusterType
+        $? | Should -BeTrue
+
+        $output | Should -Not -BeNullOrEmpty
+        $extensionExists = $output | ConvertFrom-Json | Where-Object { $_.extensionType -eq $extensionType }
+        $extensionExists | Should -Not -BeNullOrEmpty
+    }
+
+    It "Deletes the extension from the cluster" {
+        $output = az $Env:K8sExtensionName delete -c $($ENVCONFIG.arcClusterName) -g $($ENVCONFIG.resourceGroup) --cluster-type $clusterType -n $extensionName --force
+        $? | Should -BeTrue
+
+        # Extension should not be found on the cluster
+        $output = az $Env:K8sExtensionName show -c $($ENVCONFIG.arcClusterName) -g $($ENVCONFIG.resourceGroup) --cluster-type $clusterType -n $extensionName
+        $? | Should -BeFalse
+        $output | Should -BeNullOrEmpty
+    }
+
+    It "Performs another list after the delete" {
+        $output = az $Env:K8sExtensionName list -c $($ENVCONFIG.arcClusterName) -g $($ENVCONFIG.resourceGroup) --cluster-type $clusterType
+        $? | Should -BeTrue
+        $output | Should -Not -BeNullOrEmpty
+
+        $extensionExists = $output | ConvertFrom-Json | Where-Object { $_.extensionType -eq $extensionName }
+        $extensionExists | Should -BeNullOrEmpty
+    }
+}