Skip to content
New issue

Have a question about this project? Sign up for a free GitHub account to open an issue and contact its maintainers and the community.

By clicking “Sign up for GitHub”, you agree to our terms of service and privacy statement. We’ll occasionally send you account related emails.

Already on GitHub? Sign in to your account

Cover Block: Fixed Background setting doesn't work on mobile #35800

Closed
carinapilar opened this issue Aug 26, 2019 · 28 comments
Closed

Cover Block: Fixed Background setting doesn't work on mobile #35800

carinapilar opened this issue Aug 26, 2019 · 28 comments
Labels
[Closed] Won't Fix No intention to address issue. [Goal] Gutenberg Working towards full integration with Gutenberg [Pri] High [Status] Core Fix Needed A fix within the Core WordPress or Gutenberg project is required to resolve this issue. [Type] Bug User Report This issue was created following a WordPress customer report

Comments

@carinapilar
Copy link

Steps to reproduce

  1. Create a new post/page.
  2. Add the Cover block on it.
  3. Select an image in the block.
  4. Enable the "Fixed Background" option under Cover Settings.

What I expected

For the Fixed Background behavior to work anywhere. As it does on desktop:

CoverBlock

What happened instead

The Fixed Background behavior doesn't work on mobile:

CoverBlockMobile

Browser / OS version

Tested on Chrome and Safari on an iPhone XS with iOs 12.4.

Context / Source

#user-report

@carinapilar carinapilar added [Type] Bug [Goal] Gutenberg Working towards full integration with Gutenberg labels Aug 26, 2019
@nickpagz
Copy link

nickpagz commented Jan 3, 2020

Another report here:
#17652379-hc

@philnick206
Copy link

Another report here:
#19135543-hc

@ChrissiePollock
Copy link

The person from #19135543-hc added

I have noticed that it is not working on the tablet view either. And in fact, on the tablet view, it is distorting the photo, enlarging it that the photo is not even viewable.

@formosattic
Copy link

+1 on iPhone 11, 21599085-hc

@katiebethbrown
Copy link

Another report in 22161129-hc.

Cover blocks in iPad are not showing the fixed background and the image is distorted.

@lizswafford
Copy link

22823186-hc

Request for Parallax scrolling effect on iOS devices.

@aleone89
Copy link

25449616-hc

Another request made here.

@philnick206
Copy link

Another report here: #3504081-zen

@Agepeuve
Copy link

Agepeuve commented Dec 3, 2020

One more report in HC-26079990/zen-3540859

@sstabrizi
Copy link

Another report here: #26961092-hc

@MaxPhilip
Copy link

Another report: 3758720-ZD

Firefox 68.11.0 on Samsung works. Chrome does not.

@zdenys
Copy link
Contributor

zdenys commented Mar 3, 2021

Another case 28154596-hc.

@mpmedialab
Copy link

One more report → #3792547-zen

@ivan-ottinger
Copy link
Contributor

Another report (iPad Pro): 3864419-zd-woothemes

@kristenzuck kristenzuck added the User Report This issue was created following a WordPress customer report label Apr 29, 2021
@aleone89
Copy link

aleone89 commented Jul 6, 2021

Another report here: hc-30499569
iPhone XR
iOS 14.6
Safari 14

@inaikem
Copy link
Contributor

inaikem commented Jul 12, 2021

Another report in 23213008-hc + follow-up in 4132861-zen.

@marcuswisecaesar
Copy link

User reported this here and asked for an update: hc-30672648
iPhone XR
iOS 14.6
Chrome 84.0.4147.71

@renata-franco
Copy link

Another one: 4248299-zd-woothemes

@cuemarie
Copy link

Another report of this here: 31923276-hc
User is using Safari on an iPhone 7, and I can replicate the issue on Safari 14.1 on iOS 14.7

@cuemarie
Copy link

Has anyone been able to offer any workarounds for this issue?

@Robertght
Copy link

This is a core issue(WordPress/gutenberg#17718) and it looks like there's some progress(WordPress/gutenberg#32824) but it's not merged yet.

@ccwalburn
Copy link

ccwalburn commented Jul 25, 2022

Another report 29090034-hc
I can replicate it on both Safari and Chrome on my iPhone

@github-actions
Copy link

Support References

This comment is automatically generated. Please do not edit it.

  • 3504081-zen
  • 3758720-zen
  • 3792547-zen
  • 3864419-zen
  • 4132861-zen
  • 4248299-zen

@cometgrrl cometgrrl added the [Status] Core Fix Needed A fix within the Core WordPress or Gutenberg project is required to resolve this issue. label Aug 2, 2022
@desnum
Copy link

desnum commented Nov 22, 2022

The cover block background remains fixed on an Android phone, but I can confirm that it loses that parallax effect on an iPhone. This was brought up by a user in 38181454-hc.

@cometgrrl
Copy link
Contributor

The linked core issues were completed and closed in 2021.

@cometgrrl cometgrrl added the [Closed] Fixed Issues explicitly fixed with PRs. Do not use for no longer reproducible issues. label Jan 3, 2023
@carinapilar
Copy link
Author

@cometgrrl, the original issue doesn't seem to be fixed, so I'm not sure I understood why this was closed. I tested again and can still replicate it on an iPhone. Should we change this thread to a feature request for the Parallax scrolling effect on mobile?

@cometgrrl cometgrrl removed the [Closed] Fixed Issues explicitly fixed with PRs. Do not use for no longer reproducible issues. label Feb 1, 2023
@cometgrrl
Copy link
Contributor

@carinapilar Sorry for the confusion. Looking at the linked core issues, it looks like this was actually not fixed by the linked issues. However, Disable fixed cover attachment on iOS indicates that this feature is not supported in Safari on iOS.

I removed the closed fixed label, however, I'm not sure what to do with it next since it seems that it's a limitation of iOS/Safari. So either by design or won't fix might make more sense?

@carinapilar
Copy link
Author

Ah, yes, that makes sense @cometgrrl! I think won't fix sounds like a good fit. Thanks!

@cometgrrl cometgrrl added the [Closed] Won't Fix No intention to address issue. label Feb 1, 2023
Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment
Labels
[Closed] Won't Fix No intention to address issue. [Goal] Gutenberg Working towards full integration with Gutenberg [Pri] High [Status] Core Fix Needed A fix within the Core WordPress or Gutenberg project is required to resolve this issue. [Type] Bug User Report This issue was created following a WordPress customer report
Projects
None yet
Development

No branches or pull requests