diff --git a/worlds/stardew_valley/locations.py b/worlds/stardew_valley/locations.py
index 3bd1cf21e3f..103b3bd9608 100644
--- a/worlds/stardew_valley/locations.py
+++ b/worlds/stardew_valley/locations.py
@@ -6,7 +6,7 @@
 
 from . import data
 from .bundles.bundle_room import BundleRoom
-from .data.fish_data import legendary_fish, special_fish, get_fish_for_mods
+from .data.fish_data import special_fish, get_fish_for_mods
 from .data.museum_data import all_museum_items
 from .data.villagers_data import get_villagers_for_mods
 from .mods.mod_data import ModNames
@@ -206,7 +206,8 @@ def extend_fishsanity_locations(randomized_locations: List[LocationData], option
     if fishsanity == Fishsanity.option_none:
         return
     elif fishsanity == Fishsanity.option_legendaries:
-        randomized_locations.extend(location_table[f"{prefix}{legendary.name}"] for legendary in legendary_fish)
+        fish_locations = [location_table[f"{prefix}{fish.name}"] for fish in active_fish if fish.legendary]
+        randomized_locations.extend(filter_disabled_locations(options, fish_locations))
     elif fishsanity == Fishsanity.option_special:
         randomized_locations.extend(location_table[f"{prefix}{special.name}"] for special in special_fish)
     elif fishsanity == Fishsanity.option_randomized:
@@ -216,7 +217,7 @@ def extend_fishsanity_locations(randomized_locations: List[LocationData], option
         fish_locations = [location_table[f"{prefix}{fish.name}"] for fish in active_fish]
         randomized_locations.extend(filter_disabled_locations(options, fish_locations))
     elif fishsanity == Fishsanity.option_exclude_legendaries:
-        fish_locations = [location_table[f"{prefix}{fish.name}"] for fish in active_fish if fish not in legendary_fish]
+        fish_locations = [location_table[f"{prefix}{fish.name}"] for fish in active_fish if not fish.legendary]
         randomized_locations.extend(filter_disabled_locations(options, fish_locations))
     elif fishsanity == Fishsanity.option_exclude_hard_fish:
         fish_locations = [location_table[f"{prefix}{fish.name}"] for fish in active_fish if fish.difficulty < 80]
diff --git a/worlds/stardew_valley/options.py b/worlds/stardew_valley/options.py
index c2d239d2749..634de45285f 100644
--- a/worlds/stardew_valley/options.py
+++ b/worlds/stardew_valley/options.py
@@ -356,7 +356,7 @@ class QuestLocations(NamedRange):
 class Fishsanity(Choice):
     """Locations for catching a fish the first time?
     None: There are no locations for catching fish
-    Legendaries: Each of the 5 legendary fish are checks
+    Legendaries: Each of the 5 legendary fish are checks, plus the extended family if qi board is turned on
     Special: A curated selection of strong fish are checks
     Randomized: A random selection of fish are checks
     All: Every single fish in the game is a location that contains an item. Pairs well with the Master Angler Goal